Top 5 Most Profitable Things to Make with Acrylic

If you’ve got a laser cutter or UV printer and a stack of acrylic sheets ready to go, you’re sitting on some serious income potential. Acrylic is one of the most versatile and profitable materials out there for small business makers. It's durable, modern, and easy to customize, plus customers love it because it feels elevated without being outrageously expensive. 

But when it comes to choosing what to make, not all products are created equal. Some take too long to produce. Others don’t have high perceived value. And some… well, they just don’t move like you’d hoped.

Whether you're just starting or looking to expand your line, here are the top 5 most profitable things to make with acrylic, based on low material costs, strong demand, and high markup potential.

1. Personalized Keychains & Bag Tags

These are hands down one of the best acrylic products to start with. The material cost is low, production is quick, and you can sell them in bulk or one by one.

Why they're profitable:

1. Great for events, party favors, teacher gifts, and back-to-school
2. Customers love personalization
3. Easy to batch cut and customize with names, monograms, or logos
4. High perceived value despite low production cost

Tips: Use fun shapes, bold fonts, and on-trend color combos. You can also add tassels or charms for extra flair.

2. Jewelry (Especially Earrings)

Acrylic earrings are hot sellers, especially when you’re playing with color, texture, or layered designs. Clear, mirrored, glitter or even printed acrylics add visual interest and customers love unique, handmade accessories.

Why they're profitable:

• Low material cost per pair
• Can be cut and assembled quickly
• Customers often buy in multiples
• Lightweight = cheap to ship

Tips: Offer a range of sizes and styles. Bold statement earrings sell well, but minimalist studs also have strong repeat customer potential. Consider offering seasonal designs or coordinating collections.

3. Custom Business or Event Signage

Whether it’s a wedding welcome sign, a baby shower backdrop, or a branded sign for a local shop or booth; custom acrylic signage is in high demand. This category is where you’ll find some of the highest ticket pricing for acrylic work.

Why it’s profitable:

• Customers expect to pay a premium for large, custom decor
• UV printing, layered acrylic, or paint backing adds major value
• You can charge for design time and personalization

Tips: Offer signage in standard sizes and styles but allow custom color/font options. Bundling items (like table numbers, menus, or bar signs) for events is a great way to increase order value.

4. Acrylic Blanks (For Other Makers)

Selling blanks isn’t just for big suppliers. Small batch sellers are thriving by offering trendy shapes and seasonal designs to fellow makers who don’t want to cut their own.

Why they’re profitable:

• Bulk orders = higher cart values
• Return orders happen often if your quality is consistent
• Little to no customization required
• Fast to cut and ship

Tips: Use trending shapes and niches (think teacher gifts, ornaments, pet tags, or bookmarks). Be clear about sizing, film removal, and finish (glossy vs matte, single- or double-sided).

5. Personalized Home or Office Decor

Think name signs for kids’ rooms, family name plaques, desk nameplates, pet name signs, or shelf sitters. These are bestsellers year-round, especially around holidays and gifting seasons.

Why they’re profitable:

• High customization value
• Customers are emotionally attached to the purchase
• Can be made using scraps from other projects
• Can incorporate UV printing, engraving, or layered effects

Tips: Bundle with gift wrapping or offer optional hanging hardware. Use layered styles or add wood, mirror acrylic, or gold accents for a premium look.

Final Thoughts

There are so many things you can make with acrylic, but the most profitable products usually fall into one (or more) of these categories:

• Quick to produce
• Low material cost
• High perceived value
• Easily giftable or repeat purchases

If you’re just getting started, pick one or two of these product types and go deep. Create a small collection, test out pricing, and watch what sells. Once you get into a groove, scaling becomes much easier... and way more fun.

Looking for high-quality acrylic sheets to get started?
Check out our collection of acrylics in solids, glitters, mirrors, patterns, and more. We are ready to ship so you can get right to creating. Happy Crafting!